fix: defer composition runtime choice to Present Both gate in reference-analyst

The video-reference-analyst capability audit pre-locked Remotion as the
default composition engine ('Remotion is the default ... Never default to
FFmpeg when Remotion is available'). Because the analyst skill runs first
in any reference-led flow, this silently locked the runtime before the user
was ever offered a choice — violating the 'Present Both Composition Runtimes
(HARD RULE)' in AGENT_GUIDE.md, which forbids silently picking a default and
treats Remotion and HyperFrames as parallel, non-ranked runtimes.

It also omitted HyperFrames from the engine list entirely, so it was never
surfaced as an option in the reference-led path.

Update Step 2 (Capability Audit) to:
- add HyperFrames to the audited runtime list
- remove the 'Remotion is the default / preferred' framing
- defer engine selection to the AGENT_GUIDE 'Present Both' gate
- keep FFmpeg scoped to standalone ops, not composition

Closes #60
This commit is contained in:
0xDevNinja
2026-06-26 12:53:20 +05:30
parent 7ee36dd6b6
commit 00604e293d
+10 -8
View File
@@ -126,16 +126,18 @@ REFERENCE NEEDS YOUR CAPABILITIES GAP
Video clips (sci-fi) Video gen: 0/12 configured BLOCKED without key
Narration (deep male) TTS: ElevenLabs available READY
Background music Music: MusicGen available READY
Composition engine Remotion: available READY (preferred)
FFmpeg: available READY (fallback only)
Composition engine Remotion: available READY
HyperFrames: available READY
FFmpeg: available READY (standalone ops)
```
**Composition engine priority:** Remotion is the **default** composition engine for
ALL final renders — video clips, images, animated scenes, mixed content. It embeds
video natively via `<OffthreadVideo>` and handles transitions, overlays, and profile
scaling in a single React render pass. FFmpeg is only used when Remotion is
unavailable, or for standalone operations (trim, transcode, subtitle burn) outside
the composition pipeline. **Never default to FFmpeg when Remotion is available.**
**Composition engine selection:** Remotion and HyperFrames are parallel, non-ranked
composition runtimes — do NOT pre-lock either one here. When both are available, the
"Present Both Composition Runtimes (HARD RULE)" gate in `AGENT_GUIDE.md` governs the
choice: present both options to the user with tradeoffs at the proposal stage and wait
for explicit approval before locking `render_runtime`. Silently picking a default is
forbidden. FFmpeg is not a composition runtime in this flow — it is reserved for
standalone operations (trim, transcode, subtitle burn) outside the composition pipeline.
Be honest about gaps. If video generation is needed but unavailable, say so clearly: